Jiaxu Lua,b, Chunmei Zeng*a,b, Haomo Yuc
aSchool of Optoelectronic Science and Engineering & Collaborative Innovation Center of Suzhou Nano Science and Technology, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China;
bKey Lab of Advanced Optical Manufacturing Technologies of Jiangsu Province & Key Lab of Modern Optical Technologies of Education Ministry of China, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China;
cSuzhou Mason Optical Co., Ltd., Suzhou 215007, China
Corresponding author: chunmei_zeng@suda.edu.cn
ABSTRACT
The high-order aberration of the human eye is a factor that cannot be ignored in the visual correction. The design of lens that can correct the high-order aberration can reduce the negative impact on the human eye and improve the visual quality. In this paper, the optical design software ZEMAX is used to construct a personalized eye model based on the Liou eye and measured eye data. The detailed optimization process is given when fitting the wavefront aberration, so that the wavefront aberration of the target human eye and the actual human eye tend to be consistent. The constructed personalized eye model has the same optical characteristics as the actual human eye. Based on the personalized eye model, an aspherical lens is designed to correct high-order aberrations. After correction, the high-order aberrations of the target eye are reduced, and the PV of wavefront aberrations is decreased by 52.05%, RMS is reduced by 59.64%. Meanwhile, the MTF of tangential and sagittal direction increased by 180% and 135% at 100 cycles/mm respectively.
Keywords: high-order aberrations, correction, personalized eye model, aspherical lens
1. INTRODUCTION
Human eye is a relatively complex optical system, including the refractive ability and the diffraction limit of the optical system of human eye, the size of the pupil, the size of the retinal photoreceptor cells and various kinds of human eye aberrations, which will affect its imaging quality1. In order to obtain good visual experience, people have been exploring and studying for many years, among which the correction of human eye aberration is an important field that scientists have been paying attention to and making efforts. In addition to low-order aberrations represented by defocus and astigmatism, there are also high-order aberrations such as spherical aberration, coma aberration and a series of irregular high-order aberrations in the human eye2-5. These high-order aberrations will bring about problems such as decreased visual acuity, reduced contrast sensitivity and glare6. This is why, even after correcting traditional refractive problems, patients still lack overall visual clarity. Therefore, the high-order aberration of human eye is a factor that cannot be ignored in correction.
For a long time, people's vision correction mainly focuses on the use of spherical mirror to correct the defocus and astigmatism of traditional refractive problems. Correcting higher-order aberrations in the human eye was not possible until the 1990s, when a breakthrough was made in the technique of accurately measuring wavefront aberrations. In 2008, Ophthonix, an American company, funded the research and development of iZon frame glasses7, which improved vision by measuring the wavefront aberration of the human eye of order 2-6, and then fitting the corrected diopter with the optimized sphere-column mirror. Although this method introduces wavefront aberration technology, it does not consider the effect of high-order aberration on vision itself. In 2012, Li Rui et al8. used aspherical surface to design glasses that could correct high-order aberrations of human eyes. The research showed that aspherical lens correction was the most effective for eyes with large astigmatism and spherical aberration. However, if the coma and clover aberrations are large, the correction effect of aspherical lens is not obvious.
In this paper, based on the Liou model eye, combining the measured anterior and posterior corneal surface of the eye, the axial spacing of each part of the eye and the human wavefront aberration data, a personalized eye model is established. In
addition, the detailed steps are given for fitting the human wavefront aberration data, which has not been reported in the previous literature. Then, based on this personalized eye model, the aspherical glasses are optimized to reduce the negative effects of high-order aberrations on human eyes and improve visual quality. All the above contents are simulated by optical design software ZEMAX.
2.ESTABLISHMENT OF EYE MODEL
2.1 Establishment of basic eye model
Before establishing the personalized eye model, we should first establish the basic eye model, whose initial structural parameters are selected Liou eye model9, which is very similar to the optical structure and physiological structure of human eyes. Studies have shown that10,11, the change of the curvature radius of the crystalline lens in the Gullstrand-Le Grand eye model is consistent with the adjustment of the human crystalline lens, so a thin lens can be added to the front surface of the lens. The curvature radius and quadric coefficient of the anterior and posterior surfaces of the crystalline lens are selected from the Liou eye model. The refractive index value of Gullstrand-Le Grand eye model is selected. Specific parameters of the basic eye model are shown in Table 1, and Figure 1 is a schematic diagram of the basic eye model.
Table 1 Basic eye model parameters
|
Refraction surface |
Radius /mm |
Thickness /mm |
Refractive index /nd |
Abbe number /vd |
Conic coefficient |
|
Anterior corneal surface |
7.77 |
0.55 |
1.376 |
61.7 |
-0.18 |
|
Posterior corneal surface |
6.40 |
3.16 |
1.336 |
55.1 |
-0.60 |
|
Front surface of thin lens |
12.40 |
1×10-6 |
1.420 |
49.8 |
-0.94 |
|
Back surface of thin lens |
12.40 |
0 |
1.336 |
55.1 |
-0.94 |
|
Anterior crystalline lens |
12.40 |
1.59 |
GradA |
60.3 |
-0.94 |
|
Virtual plane |
Infinity |
2.43 |
GradP |
~66.8 |
- |
|
Posterior crystalline lens |
-8.10 |
16.27 |
1.336 |
55.1 |
0.96 |
|
Retina |
-12.0 |
- |
- |
- |
- |

Figure 1 The structure of the basic eye model
2.2 Establishment of personalized eye model
Based on the constructed basic eye model, we used the measured data, including the anterior and posterior surface parameters of the cornea, the axial length between the refraction planes of the human eye and the wavefront aberration of the human eye, to complete the fitting of the personalized eye model. The data obtained by the following detection are all from the same human eye.
The ALLEGRO OCULYZER anterior segment analyzer is used to measure the corneal topographic map of the actual human eyes, and the corneal thickness is 0.462 mm, the reference spherical curvature radius of the front surface of the cornea is 8.45 mm, and the reference spherical curvature radius of the back surface is 6.19 mm. The appearance of the instrument is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2 ALLEGRO OCULYZER Anterior Segment Analyzer
The axial length between refractive surfaces of the eye is measured by SUOER ophthalmic optical biometric SW-9000, as shown in Figure 3. The measured results included corneal thickness, anterior chamber depth, crystalline lens thickness and vitreous depth. The average of the data is taken for 5 times, as shown in Table 2.

Figure 3 SUOER Ophthalmic optical biometrics SW-9000
Table 2 The axial length between refractive surfaces of the eye
|
The axial length |
Value /mm |
|
Corneal thickness |
0.454 |
|
Anterior chamber depth |
3.52 |
|
Crystalline lens thickness |
3.45 |
|
Vitreous depth |
19.55 |
The corneal thickness, anterior and posterior surface reference spherical curvature radius and axial length data obtained above are input into the basic eye model.
The wavefront aberration data of human eyes are detected by the wavefront aberration measuring instrument. The fitting of wavefront aberration is completed by optimizing the basic eye model. The expected result after optimization is that the personalized eye model is consistent with the actual wavefront aberration of human eyes. The following method is adopted for simulation: The first three terms of human wavefront aberration (order 0-1) represent constant terms, the tilt in Y and X directions respectively, which has no effect on the overall human aberration. In addition, since the latter aberration coefficient is of little significance in practical application, it is generally not considered, so we choose the aberration data of order 2-4 for optimization. Table 3 lists the detected wavefront aberration of the eye and its physical significance. First, the radius of curvature of the anterior crystalline lens and the depth of the vitreous body are taken as optimization variables, aiming to share defocus between the crystalline lens and the vitreous body. The optimization function ZERN is used, and the optimization target value is the data in Table 3. Then we choose Zernike Fringe Sag Surface to define the face shape of the anterior corneal surface, which is defined by Even Aspherical Surface and some additional aspheric conditions determined by the Zernike Fringe coefficient, in an expression as follows:

where r is the radial ray coordinate in unit of lens length, N is the Zernike coefficient in the sequence, Ai is the coefficient of the ith Zernike edge polynomial, ρ is the normalized radial ray coordinate, φ is the ray coordinate expressed by the Angle.
We set the Zenick Fringe coefficient Ai in the Zernike Fringe Sag Surface as a variable for optimization to share astigmatism and high-order aberration. In order to ensure the smooth progress of optimization, we adopted the optimization strategy of fitting low-order aberrations first and then high-order aberrations: First, low-order aberrations (C3-C5) are fitted into the eye model, then the aberrations (C7, C8), the fitting of clover (C6, C9) and four-leaf clover (C10, C14), and then the optimization of second-order astigmatism (C11, C13). At this time, some initial quantities are given to spherical aberrations (C12), and finally the fitting of spherical aberrations (C12). The detected wavefront aberration data (order 2-
4) RMS is 0.8031, and the fitting result is 0.8089. Therefore, the final optimization result almost converged to the target value, and a complete personalized eye model is established effectively.
Table 3 The wavefront aberrations and their physical significance that need to be fitted
|
Wavefront aberration |
Value |
Physical significance |
|
C3 |
-0.10478 |
Astigmatism in 45/135°direction |
|
C4 |
2.35525 |
defocus |
|
C5 |
0.01230 |
Astigmatism in 0/90°direction |
|
C6 |
-0.34828 |
Clover in 45/135°direction |
|
C7 |
0.36229 |
Coma in Y direction |
|
C8 |
-0.73601 |
Coma in X direction |
|
C9 |
-0.34865 |
Clover in 0/90°direction |
|
C10 |
-0.13416 |
Four-leaf clover in 45/135°direction |
|
C11 |
-0.15473 |
Second order Y direction astigmatism |
|
C12 |
1.07088 |
Spherical aberration |
|
C13 |
-0.26952 |
Second order X direction astigmatism |
|
C14 |
0.05994 |
Four-leaf clover Astigmatism in 0/90°direction |
3.DESIGN OF LENS FOR CORRECTING HIGH-ORDER ABERRATIONS
3.1 Design method
Usually, the refractive index of the resin lens is 1.49~1.74. The lens designed in this paper selects the resin material with refractive index of 1.6 and Abbe number of 40. The center thickness of the lens is set as 2 mm and the distance between the lens and the personalized human eye model is 13 mm. Since we obtained human eye wavefront aberration data at 6.84 mm, the pupil diameter is set at 6.84 mm and the wavelength is set at 550 nm. Both surfaces of the lens are provided with Odd Aspherical Surface, with its radius of curvature and aspherical coefficient (α1-α8) as optimization variables, and with ZERN function, whose target function value is set to 0, to eliminate the system's wavefront aberrations. Then the MTFT of meridional plane and the MTFS operand of sagittal plane are set to control the MTF value. After many times of optimization, the design of correcting high-order aberration lens is completed. The optimized resin lens data is shown in Table 4.
Table 4 Optimized resin lens parameters
|
The front surface of the lens |
The back surface of the lens |
|
|
Radius of curvature /mm |
281.820 |
146.562 |
|
α1 |
0 |
0 |
|
α2 |
7.930´10-4 |
-1.314´10-3 |
|
α3 |
2.515´10-3 |
4.237´10-4 |
|
α4 |
1.394´10-4 |
1.340´10-3 |
|
α5 |
1.709´10-4 |
1.234´10-4 |
|
α6 |
5.917´10-5 |
-1.410´10-5 |
|
α7 |
8.190´10-6 |
3.577´10-7 |
|
α8 |
-1.773´10-6 |
8.755´10-6 |
|
conic |
3.000 |
2.000 |
3.2 Results and analysis
The initial human wave aberration PV=7.3457, RMS=1.6661. After correction, PV=3.5225, RMS=0.6725, the former decreases by 52.05% and the latter reduces by 59.64%, which are significantly improved. Table 5 shows the Zernike coefficient of the system after correction. Compared with before correction, it can be seen that all Zernike aberrations decrease and the tangential and sagittal MFT increased by 180% and 135% at 100 cycles/mm respectively. Figure 4 shows the comparison of MTF before and after optimization. It is proved that the designed aspherical lens can effectively reduce the high-order aberrations of human eyes and improve the visual quality.
Table 5 Optimization result
|
Before correction |
After correction |
|
|
PV |
7.3457 |
3.5225 |
|
RMS |
1.6661 |
0.6725 |
|
C3 |
-0.1048 |
-0.0125 |
|
C4 |
2.3553 |
0.4035 |
|
C5 |
0.0123 |
0.0013 |
|
C6 |
-0.3483 |
-0.2578 |
|
C7 |
0.3622 |
0.2001 |
|
C8 |
-0.7360 |
-0.4618 |
|
C9 |
-0.3487 |
-0.2574 |
|
C10 |
-0.1342 |
-0.0880 |
|
C11 |
-0.1547 |
-0.05282 |
|
C12 |
1.0709 |
-0.1735 |
|
C13 |
-0.2695 |
-0.0939 |
|
C14 |
0.0599 |
0.0400 |

Figure 4 Comparison of MTF before and after optimization
4.CONCLUSION
In this paper, the optical design software ZEMAX is used to construct a personalized eye model based on the Liou eye and the measured data. In addition, the detailed optimization process is given when fitting wavefront aberrations, which makes the simulation results consistent with the actual wavefront aberrations of human eyes. By using the personalized eye model obtained, the aspherical lens is optimized, and a lens capable of correcting high-order aberrations of human eyes is designed. The design results reduced the high-order aberrations of human eyes, which proves to be helpful for improving the visual quality of human eyes, and has certain reference value for correcting high-order aberrations of human eyes. The deficiency of this paper is that it does not consider the error caused by the movement of human eyes in the design, and there is also no analysis of the feasibility of processing. Hope to continue the discussion in the future work.
REFERENCES
- Campbell, F. W., Green, D. G. (1965) Optical and retinal factors affecting visual resolution. The Journal of physiology, 3:576. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/5880378/
- Koomen, M., Tousey, R., Sclnik, R. (1950) THE SPHERICAL ABERRATION OF THE EYE. Optometry and Vision Science, 7: 370-376. doi:10.1097/00006324-195007000-00012.
- Howland, H. C., Howland B.(1977).A subjective method for the measurement of monochromatic* aberrations of the eye. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 11: 1508-1518. doi:10.1364/JOSA.67.001508.
- Jansonius, N. M., Kooijman, A. C. (1998). The effect of spherical and other aberrations upon the modulation transfer of the defocussed human eye. Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics, 6: 504-513. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1046/j.1475-1313.1998.00391.x
- Wang, Y., Wang Z. Q., Guo, H. Q., Quan W. (2005). Effect of advanced aberration of human eye on visual function. Acta optica, 11: 1519-1525. https://www.researching.cn/ArticlePdf/m00006/2005/25/11/gxxb-2005- 11-1519-7.pdf.
- Liang, J., Williams, D. R., Miller, D. T. (1997). Supernormal vision and high-resolution retinal imaging through adaptive optics. JOSA A, 11: 2884-2892. https://opg.optica.org/josaa/fulltext.cfm?uri=josaa-14-11- 2884&id=2024&ibsearch=false.
- Seiple, W. H., Szlyk, J. P. (2008). Vision Performance Provided by the iZon® Spectacle Lens System. Review of Optometry, 2. https://chicagolighthouse.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/1008_Ophthonics-Final.pdf.
- Li, R., Wang, Z. Q., Liu, Y. J., Mu, G. G. (2012) A method to design aspheric spectacles for correction of high- order aberrations of human eye. Science China Technological Sciences, 55: 1391–1401. 10.1007/s11431-012- 4762-4.
- Liou, H. L., Brennan, N. A. (1997). Anatomically accurate, finite model eye for optical modeling. JOSA A, 8: 1684-1695. https://opg.optica.org/josaa/fulltext.cfm?uri=josaa-14-8-1684&id=1839&ibsearch=false.
- Garner, L. F., Smith, G. (1997). Changes in equivalent and gradient refractive index of the crystalline lens with accommodation. Optometry and vision science, 2: 114-119. https://journals.lww.com/optvissci/Abstract/1997/02000/Changes_in_Equivalent_and_Gradient_Refractive.24.a spx.
- Koretz, J. F., Cook, C. A., Kaufman, P. L. (2002). Aging of the human lens: changes in lens shape upon accommodation and with accommodative loss. JOSA A, 1: 144-151. https://opg.optica.org/josaa/fulltext.cfm?uri=josaa-19-1-144&id=67236&ibsearch=false.

