Hongliang Yaoa, Chunmei Zeng*a,b, Haomo Yuc
aSchool of Optoelectronic Science and Engineering, Soochow University, No.1 Shizi Street, Suzhou 215006, China; bKey Lab of Advanced Optical Manufacturing Technologies of Jiangsu Province &
Key Lab of Modern Optical Technologies of Education Ministry of China, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China; cSuzhou Mason Optical Co., Ltd., Suzhou 215007, China
* Corresponding author: chunmei_zeng@suda.edu.cn
ABSTRACT
Specially designed frame glasses have shown increasingly significant performance in myopia prevention and control in clinical trials. However, public studies on the modulation of high-order aberrations related to eyeglass frames remain scarce. This article designs eyeglass lenses with high-order aberrations and myopic defocusing by linking the eye model and frame glasses, and simulates the optical model of the glasses-eye for 300 degree myopic patients. When the high- order aberration modulation unit is not set for the glasses, the defocusing value of the Y-axis direction at a -14° field of view corresponding to the change in the external surface power of the lens defocusing unit microlens under static field, and the defocusing change of the external surface power of the defocusing unit micro lens is set to 6 diopters, with a static vertical field of view ranging from -28.5° ~ 28.5° (at 1° increments). This article discussed the correlation between the base arc curvature radius of the high-order aberration modulation unit's toric microstructure and high-order aberrations in the designed eyeglass under static observation in the Y-direction. Corresponding empirical formulas have been established. This research will be conducive to the development of high-order aberration modulation glasses. Keywords: High-order aberration modulation, myopia prevention and control, eye model, glasses design
1. INTRODUCTION
A systematic follow-up study[1] shows that in the past 15 years, the incidence rate of myopia in East Asia has risen rapidly, a trend now spreading globally. The progression rate of myopia varies among different age groups, as shown in Figure 1: the progression rate of myopia in children aged 6 to 9 is -0.50 to -1.00 diopters (D) per year, while those over 10 years old exhibit a rate of -0.35 to -0.75 D/year. The average annual progression of myopia in most myopic patients will slow down over time, with most individuals stabilizing before age 20. The International Myopia Institute (IMI) reported in 2019 that approximately 87% of children who suffer from high myopia at the age of 11 develop myopia at the age of 7 or younger, or exhibited a myopia progression for four years or more[2]. Therefore, early prevention of myopia in school-aged children and adolescents is crucial for reducing visual impairment in the future.

Figure 1. Refractive shift among myopic children by age[2].
Fourth International Conference on Optics and Image Processing (ICOIP 2024), edited by Xiaotao Hao, Chuan Qin, Proc. of SPIE Vol. 13254, 132541C © 2024 SPIE · 0277-786X · doi: 10.1117/12.3039156
Proc. of SPIE Vol. 13254 132541C-1
Previous research on high-order aberrations (HOAs) of the human eye has mainly focused on how to correct them (such as Suliman et al.'s design of soft contact lenses in 2019[3]), the relationship between HOAs and eye-related factors[4,5], corneal reshaping surgery using high-order aberrations, and the impact of HOAs on the treatment of eye diseases[6]. Evidence suggested that HOAs are significantly linked to myopia progression and axial elongation in myopic children corrected with monofocal glasses[7]. Considering the advantages of high popularity, low cost, non-invasive nature, and easy replacement of frame glasses, exploring their potential to slow myopia progression in children and adolescents presents a unique advantage. And multi-point myopia defocus designed glasses: with a central area that can correct clear vision, microlenses are arranged around the lens to produce periretinal myopia defocus, thereby delaying the progression of myopia,this technology has been successfully commercialized. Far, this study attempts to design eyeglass lenses that can modulate high-order aberrations based on myopic defocusing.
2. METHODOLOGY
2.1 Eye model
The foundation of study involved simulating the basic eye using optical design software Zemax. The basic eye was modified based on the Liou eye model[8], with structural parameters detailed in Table 1. The eye model was designed with an axial length of 23.97 mm and a pupil diameter of 4 mm. To streamline analysis, we assumed no inclination or eccentricity at the pupil.
Table 1. Eye model structural parameters.

The anterior surface of lens front and virtual surface are based on the standard surface, and the refractive index n of the medium can be freely defined, as shown in formula (1).

In Table 1, the Grad A on the anterior surface of the lens corresponds to n0=1.368, nr2=-1.978*10-3, nr4=0, nr6=0, nz1=4.9057*10-2, nz2=-1.5427*10-2, nz3=0; The Grad B on the virtual surface corresponds to n0=1.407, nr2=-1.978*10-3, nr4=0, nr6=0, nz1=0, nz2=-6.605*10-3, nz3=0.
2.2 Wavefront aberration of human eyes
In optometry, the first 6 orders of Zernike polynomials are mainly used to represent the wavefront aberrations of the human eye. The wavefront aberrations specified by The Optical Society of America (OSA)[9] correspond to the Zernike standard coefficients in Zemax software, as outlined in Table 2. This approach allows for a precise and standardized representation of ocular aberrations, facilitating a more accurate simulation and analysis.
Table 2. Meaning of Zernike standard coefficient aberration in Zemax.

3. MODELS AND DATA
(vision correction area) can correct the spherical and cylindrical refractive errors typical in myopia patients. It is designed according to the patient's eyeglass prescription; 2, Myopia defocus unit (distributed with several convex spherical microlenses arranged in a circular array), which produces a certain degree of myopia defocus; 3, The high order aberration modulation unit is composed of several ring structures involved in regulating the HOA of the human eye. The schematic diagram of the outer surface of the eyeglass lens is shown in Figure 2(a), with the number of turns and the order of the band increasing from the center of the lens to the edge; The arrangement relationship of the three optical units is shown in Figure 2(b), where r represents the radial distance, which is located in the XOY plane; The myopic defocusing units are uniformly distributed on the circumference, and the distribution intervals at the same radial distance are represented by the unit arc length. The setting of the unit arc length can control the number of units on each ring of the unit microlens. The unit arc length, ring spacing d, the diameter D2 of the defocused unit microlens, and the radial width D3 of the ring band jointly determine the density of the microstructure on the eyeglass lens.

Figure 2. (a: left) Schematic diagram of eyeglass lenses; (b:right) Schematic diagram of three unit layouts in the XOY plane.
Step1: Assuming that the prescription of a myopic patient is spherical diopter (3 D) and cylindrical diopter (0 D), the patient's myopia growth is only manifested as axial myopia. Based on this, a myopic eye model was designed, which can ideally used changes in the length of the vitreous cavity to reflect changes in the degree of myopia in the eye model. According to the prescription, a single focus left crescent negative lens was designed as the primary mirror unit, with spherical inner and outer surfaces. The diameter of the mother mirror is 60 mm, with a medium thickness of 1.3 mm selected; The mother mirror material is polycarbonate (PC), with a refractive index of 1.56, Abbe number of 37, and a specific gravity of 1.23 g/cm3. The comprehensive structural parameters are summarized in Table 3.
Table 3. Structural parameters of the mother mirror unit.

In Zemax, the aperture type was set to a floating aperture size with a pupil diameter of 4 mm, and the toe type was set to uniform; Set three fields of view (FOV) and adjusted their weights accordingly: the 0° FOV in the Y-direction was given a weight of 1, the 10° FOV a weight of 0.2, and the 14° FOV a weight of 0.15. Under bright vision, the wavelength adopted a single wavelength of 0.555 μm. The other data was based on the basic eye model data in Table 1. The vitreous thickness of the eye model was treated as a variable, and the mother lens was placed 12 mm ahead of the corneal vertex to optimize the optical model of the glasses-eye. This configuration resulted in a vitreous body length of approximately 17.306 mm and a total axial length of the eye of 25.036 mm.
Step2: Selecting a FOV of Y-direction 14° as the principal ray direction for subsequent optical unit design, with the same material as the mother mirror unit. Initially, it was necessary to determine the Y-direction coordinate when the main light outside the field of view axis intersects with the outer surface of the primary mirror, in order to determine the radial distance when the normal of the first microstructure vertex in the Y-direction of the first circle of microlenses in the myopic defocus unit intersected with the outer surface of the mother mirror; Then determined the aperture of the field of view on the outer surface of the mother mirror, as depicted in the locally enlarged image in Figure 3. Utilizing the REAY and REAZ operands in Zemax, combined with normalized FOV and normalized pupil settings, the radial distance r was 3.802 mm, ∆y was 4.318 mm, ∆z was 0.058 mm approximately. According to the Pythagorean theorem, the aperture of the ray passed through the Y-direction outside the axis at -14° FOV on the outer surface of the mother mirror was approximately 4.3186 mm.

Figure 3. Partial schematic diagram of off axis field of view mother mirror for light transmission.
The position relationship between the microlens of the first circle of the myopia defocus unit and the outer surface of the mother mirror in the YOZ plane in the Y direction can be illustrated in Figure 4. The curvature radius of the outer surface of the mother mirror is denoted as R1, the curvature radius of the outer surface of the defocus unit microlens is denoted as R2, the diameter of the microlens is denoted as D2, and the vector height from the vertex of the micro lens to the outer surface of the mother mirror is denoted as G2. The center position of the microlens can be determined by the length F2 and rotation angle 𝜃, which can be calculated using the following formula:


Figure 4. Partial schematic diagram of off axis field of view mother mirror for light transmission.
Set the surface shape of the defocus unit microlens as spherical (opical power of 6 D and a diameter of 2 mm), and the radial distance of the first circle of microstructure is 3.802 mm; The initial surface shape of the outer surface of the high order aberration modulation unit ring band microstructure was set as toric with a base arc power of 4 D and a radial Proc. of SPIE Vol. 13254 132541C-5 width of 1.5 mm (D3). The calculation principle of the center position of the base arc of the YOZ plane toric is the same as formula (2) to (4). The center position of the base arc can be determined by the length F3 and rotation angle 𝜃. with the curvature radius (R3) and the vector height (G3) from the vertex of the base arc on the outer surface to the outer surface of the mother mirror. G2=3.572 μm, G3=1.004 μm, the interval between adjacent ring strips was set as 3.8 mm, The eyeglass lenses are set with 6 rings and a unit arc length of 4 mm. The reference data for microstructure position were detailed in Table 4.
Step3: Utilizing the 3D CAD software Solidworks, completed the modeling of the initial eyeglass lenses. The main and left views were depicted in Figure 5, and the diameter of the central vision correction area of the initial structural mother lens is about 5.604 mm.
Table 4. Position data of YOZ cross-sectional lens microstructure.


Figure 5. Initial structure of eyeglass lenses - front and left views.
4. RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
The investigation into the optical performance of the eyeglass lens, initially featuring only the mother lens, revealed that the defocus value in the Y-axis direction at a -14° FOV within the static field of view of the glasses-eye model was 0.047987 λ, indicating that the actual wavefront was positioned behind the retina. Given that the power of the outer surface of the mother mirror is 2 D, we opted to explore a range of optical powers for the outer surface of the myopic defocus unit between 4 to 10 D, increasing in 1 D increments, without incorporating a high-order aberration modulation unit. The observed defocus situation was summarized in Table 5. The data pertaining to Z4 defocus exhibited a linear relationship, allowing us to employ formula (5) for estimating the wavefront defocus under varying powers of the myopic defocus unit's outer surface in the static observation Y-direction -14° field. Here, the optical power value x of the myopic defocus unit's outer surface served as the independent variable, while the corresponding Z4 defocus value acted as the dependent variable.
![]()
Table 5. Static field of view axis -14 ° field of view defocus data with changes in optical power.

Set the external surface power of the defocus unit microlens to 6 D, without setting a high-order aberration modulation unit. The defocus variation of the static vertical field of view from -28.5° to 28.5°, with a step size of 1°, as depicted in Figure 6. The vertical axis of the coordinates is the defocus amount in the form of wavefront aberration. In this article, the positive value of Z4 indicates that the defocus amount is located in front of the retina, while the negative value of Z4 indicates that the defocus amount is positioned behind the retina. Due to the symmetry of lens arrangement, the defocus distribution in the vertical field of view is approximately symmetrical, while the defocus situation in the horizontal field of view is similar.

Figure 6. Static vertical field of view defocus change map.
The initial structure of the mother mirror and myopia defocus unit remained unchanged, while maintaining the radial width of the toroidal surface microstructure of the higher-order aberration modulation unit, and the base arc curvature radius of the toric was changed. This aimed to Analyze the relationship between the base arc curvature radius R3 and the higher-order aberration amount when observing the Y-direction -14° field at the static.
The study selected a total of 9 data points, including the base curve powers of 3.7 D, 4 D, 4.5 D, 5 D, 5.5 D, 6 D, 7 D, 8 D, and 9 D, to ensure a smooth decrease in the calculated curvature radius. When base curve power was 10 D, the highest point on the outer surface of the defocused unit microlens is lower than that of the high-order aberration modulation unit microstructure, which was not in line with modeling.
Recorded the Zernike standard term coefficient values of the lens with only the mother mirror and defocus unit microlens in the Y-direction at a -14 ° FOV. The RMS of wavefront aberration values for the center of mass in Zemax eliminate the effects of displacement and tilt. By eliminating them, the RMS (Root Mean Square) of the HOAs of the eye in this field can be determined to be 0.932937 λ (0.555 μm), maintained to six decimal places. Recorded several high-order aberration components that may be involved in delaying myopia, with an initial value denoted as Zi0, where i represents the ranking order of the Zernike standard term coefficients in Zemax. The vertical coma Z70 was -0.141717 λ, Horizontal coma Z80 was 0.000001 λ, Tilted trefoil Z90 was -0.003296 λ, Horizontal trefoil Z100 was 0 λ, Spherical aberration Z110 was -0.454283 λ, The horizontal secondary astigmatism Z120 was -0.005588 λ, Tilted secondary astigmatism Z130 was 0 λ, Second-order horizontal coma Z160 was -0.000001 λ, Second-order vertical coma Z170 was -0.008084 λ, Secondary spherical aberration Z220 was 0.362791 λ.
Modeling eyeglass lenses with different base arc curvature radii for higher-order aberration modulation units, and recording higher-order aberration data in the Y-direction at -14° FOV during static observation in the glasses-eye optical system, as shown in Table 6. The amount of microstructure involved in modulating higher-order aberration was represented by ∆Zi (Zi-Zi0). Regression analysis of the data revealed that the base arc curvature radius R3 of the toroidal surface was related to vertical coma, tilted trefoil, spherical aberration, horizontal secondary astigmatism, second-order vertical coma, secondary spherical aberration and total high-order aberration. Figure 7 shows the scatter distribution and regression lines of six high-order aberration increments and R3, where the tilted trefoil increment and spherical aberration increment have a linear relationship with the base arc curvature radius, and the increment decreases with the increase of the base arc curvature radius. The vertical coma increment, horizontal secondary astigmatism increment, second-order vertical coma increment, secondary spherical aberration increment, and total high-order aberration increment are nonlinearly correlated with R3. The empirical formula can be seen from equations (6)~(12). There is no significant correlation between horizontal coma, horizontal trefoil, tilted secondary astigmatism, second-order horizontal coma and the radius of curvature R3. It can be imagined that the ability to modulate specific aberrations by precisely adjusting the curvature of the microstructure underscores the potential for creating more effective and customized eyeglass lenses for myopia management.
Table 6. Static observation at Y-direction -14° field of view high-order aberration standard wavefront data.


Figure 7. Scatter plots and regression lines of partial high-order aberration increments as a function of the radius of curvature of the fundamental arc.
Established the correlation between the radius of curvature R3 of the base arc and the wavefront aberration expressed by the Zernike standard polynomial (refer to Figure 7). The range of R3 is between 62.222222 mm and 151.351351 mm, the empirical formula was as follows:

In the equation, represents the judgment coefficient of the regression equation, and the closer its value is to 1, the higher the degree of fitting of the equation.
5. CONCLUSIONS
This paper aims to investigate the modulation of high-order aberrations in designed glasses and their impact on myopic defocusing. It proposes a design that links the eye model and frame glasses to simulate the optical model for 300-degree myopic patients. The study explores the correlation between the base arc curvature radius of the high-order aberration modulation unit's toric microstructure and high-order aberrations under static observation. This research contributes to the development of high-order aberration modulation glasses, providing valuable insights into myopia prevention and control.
REFERENCES
[1] R A R, V V K, K A W, et al. Global variations and time trends in the prevalence of childhood myopia, a systematic review and quantitative meta-analysis: implications for aetiology and early prevention. The British journal of ophthalmology. 2016, 100(7): 882-890.
[2] Wolffsohn JS, Flitcroft DI, Gifford KL, et al. IMI - Myopia Control Reports Overview and Introduction. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2019 Feb 28;60(3):M1-M19.
[3] Suliman A, Rubin A. Corrigendum: A review of higher order aberrations of the human eye. African Vision and Eye Health. 2019, 78(1).
[4] Rebika D, Divya S, Murugesan V, et al. Biomechanical properties of cornea and ocular aberrations in myopic eyes. Indian journal of ophthalmology. 2023 Dec 15.
[5] Hassan H, Shima M, Alireza J, et al. The association between ocular biometric components and corneal aberrations. Clinical experimental optometry. 2023 Oct 16, 1-7.
[6] K J L, J S V, Sin-Wan C, et al. The influence of orthokeratology compression factor on ocular higher-order aberrations. Clinical experimental optometry. 2020,103(1), 123-128.
[7] Hiraoka Takahiro, Kotsuka Junko, Kakita Tetsuhiko, Okamoto Fumiki, Oshika Tetsuro. Relationship between higher-order wavefront aberrations and natural progression of myopia in schoolchildren. Scientific reports. 2017, 7(1).
[8] Liou H L, Brennan N A. Anatomically accurate. finite model eye for optical modeling. Opt Soc Am A Opt Image Sci Vis. 1997 Aug, 14(8), 1684-95.
[9] Ophthalmics-methods for reporting optical aberrations of eyes. ANSI. Z80.28-2017, 2017-08-21.

