Saddle-shaped microstructure array eyeglass based on contrast principle

Dec 20, 2024Leave a message

Jialing Houa,b, Chunmei Zeng*a,b, Haomo Yuc aSchool of Optoelectronic Science and Engineering, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China; bKey Lab of Advanced Optical Manufacturing Technologies of Jiangsu Province & Key Lab of Modern Optical Technologies of Education Ministry of China, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China;

cSuzhou Mason Optical Co., Ltd., Suzhou 215007, China * Corresponding author: chunmei_zeng@suda.edu.cn

 

ABSTRACT

 

In order to more intuitively judge the relationship between the myopia prevention and control effect of the myopia prevention and control frame glasses and the microstructure parameters of the glasses, this paper designs a saddle surface microstructure array glasses based on the contrast principle, and uses the relationship between the MTF value and the microstructure parameters to establish a quantitative model. The design results show that within the acceptable imaging signal range of the human eye, the saddle surface microstructure array lens can make the light passing through the microstructure unable to converge and image, which greatly reduces the imaging contrast of the retina. When a certain spatial frequency in the range of 0~43lp/mm is selected, the maximum vector height of the microlens is in the range of 0~10μm, and the maximum vector height of the microlens and the MTF value under the maximum off-axis field of view show a nonlinear negative correlation. Therefore, the empirical formula of the maximum vector height and MTF value of the microlens of the spectacle lens is established, and the quantitative analysis of the microstructure parameters and contrast signal of the spectacle lens is completed. This work helps the lens designer to control the contrast control of myopia prevention and control more accurately through the microstructure parameters. At the same time, through analysis, it is found that in the case of relatively small light loss, compared with the spherical microstructure, the saddle surface microstructure has a better effect on reducing the contrast, which is more helpful to reduce the visual quality and slow down the development of myopia.

 

Keywords: Frame glasses, Myopia prevention and control, Microstructured array, contrast ratio

 

1. INTRODUCTION

 

According to the World Vision Report released by the World Health Organization, nearly 2.6 billion of the world 's 7 billion people have developed myopia as a functional eye disease by 2020[1]. It is estimated that by 2050, about 5 billion people around the world will develop myopia[2]-[3]. At present, there are mainly myopia prevention and control measures such as outdoor activities, drug treatment and optical intervention [4]. Compared with the difficulty of outdoor activities, the risk of drug treatment, and the expensive price of corneal contact lenses, wearing myopia prevention and control frame glasses as an optical intervention that can correct myopia and inhibit the development of myopia at the same time has the characteristics of safety, comfort, convenience, and economy. Therefore, for myopia patients at this stage, wearing myopia prevention and control frame glasses is more easily accepted by most patients and their families. At present, the microstructured lenses used to delay the deepening of myopia in adolescents can be pided into lenses based on the principle of myopic defocus or lenses based on the principle of higher-order aberrations.The lens based on the principle of myopic defocusing will gradually weaken the adjustment effect with the extension of wearing time. The lens based on the principle of higher-order aberrations has certain indirectness in evaluating the effect of myopia prevention and control. It is difficult to directly quantify the relationship between the indicators of higher-order aberrations and the microstructure parameters of the lens with the current data accumulation. However, there are few myopia prevention and control glasses designed based on the contrast principle. Therefore, it is necessary to use different designs to more fully reduce the contrast signal to intervene in the development of myopia. At the same time, the myopia prevention and control effect of the glasses is quantified in order to obtain the myopia control signal matching with the myopia patients more accurately and quickly.

 

2. CONTRAST PRINCIPLE

 

During the process of viewing objects, the eye always tries to focus on the retina in order to achieve maximum contrast. However, the focal point of the incident light around the retina of the normal eye or the myopia eye wearing conventional myopia glasses is behind the retina. Therefore, in order to obtain the maximum contrast, the eyes will make the retina try to approach the focal point of the incident light, resulting in the increase of the axial length, which leads to the gradual development of myopia or the deepening of myopia. Experiments on the development of myopia have shown that the occurrence and development of myopia are triggered by retinal blur signals[5]-[9]. The contrast signal in children 's bipolar cells is a signal of eye growth, and the reduction of contrast signal will slow down the growth rate of eyes[10]. At present, the lenses based on the contrast principle on the market mainly consider using non-transparent microstructures to block the passage of some light, so as to reduce the contrast around the lenses. This kind of method is relatively difficult to quantitatively evaluate the relationship between the myopia prevention and control effect of the lenses and the microstructure parameters. If the microstructure with alternating positive and negative curvature is added to the spectacle lens, more irregular changes such as convergence or pergence of light through the microstructure will occur, and the imaging cannot be converged within the acceptable imaging signal range of the human eye, so as to reduce the contrast of retinal imaging, so that the eyeball will no longer grow in order to obtain the maximum contrast, and the effect of inhibiting the progression of myopia can also be achieved. Therefore, this paper designs a saddle surface microstructure array lens based on the principle of contrast. The microlens is used to scatter the incident light, so as to reduce the stimulation of the incident light on the periphery of the retina, reduce the contrast of the retina, and achieve the effect of inhibiting the growth of the eye axis.

 

3. EYEGLASS LENS DESIGN

 

3.1 Layout of microstructure and determination of design parameters

In order to ensure the stability of dynamic visual quality and ensure that the number of microlenses in the pupil will not change greatly with the change of the position of the spectacle lens, this paper chooses the array mode of close arrangement of microstructure, that is, the microstructure area is pided by close splicing of regular hexagon, and then the microstructure array filled with microlenses of regular hexagon inscribed circle size is arranged[11].The microstructure array is distributed outside the central blank area of the front surface of the mother lens, and the diameter of the central blank area is 6mm.The radial diameter of the microlens is selected to be 1mm. In order to facilitate the discussion of the establishment of a rectangular coordinate system, the optical center of the front surface of the mother lens is taken as the origin. The two directions along the radial direction of the mother lens are the X-axis and Y-axis of the three-dimensional coordinate system, and the Z-axis of the three-dimensional coordinate system is along the optical axis direction. The control area with a diameter of about 25 mm is added to the front surface of the mother lens. The obtained front view of the spectacle lens is shown in Figure. 1, and a regular hexagon grid of the control area is shown in Figure. 1. In order to make the maximum off-axis field of view completely cover a regular hexagonal grid, and make the selected pupil diameter of the human eye in the range of 2 ~ 3mm with relatively good illumination conditions, the pupil diameter of the myopic model is selected as 2.8mm, and the full field of view is 33 ⁰. The three fields of view are set to 0 ⁰, 8 ⁰ and 16.5 ⁰ respectively, and the wavelength used in the lens-eye system is 550 nm.

 

info-462-288

Figure 1. Front view of eyeglass lenses.

 

3.2 Calculation of mother lens parameters and construction of myopia model eyes

According to the requirements of the processing technology, the lens diameter D is set to 60 mm, the center thickness of the lens is 1.3 mm, and the shape is a meniscus spherical lens, which is later called the mother lens. The refractive index of the selected resin lens is 1.56, and the Abbe number is 32. According to the degree of myopia - 3D, the focal power of the front surface of the mother lens is set to 2D, and the focal power of the back surface is - 5D. Thus, the curvature radius of the front and rear surfaces of the mother lens can be calculated.

 

The Liou standard model eye was used as the initial structure of the myopic model eye. The mother lens corresponding to the correction of myopic ametropia was inserted in front of the Liou standard model eye. The distance from the apex of the posterior surface of the lens to the apex of the anterior surface of the cornea was 12 mm. The pupil diameter, wavelength and field of view of the system were set according to the determined system parameters. The vitreous thickness of the Liou standard model eye was used as a variable to optimize the model eye corresponding to the myopic form.

 

3.3 Modeling of eyeglass lenses

In order to calculate the optical structure parameters of the saddle surface, the vertex vector height of the parabola with downward opening is set to 1μm ( the vertex vector height of the parabola is defined as the distance between its vertex and the intersection point of the vertex normal line and the front surface of the mother lens ), and the maximum vector height of the parabola with upward opening is 2, 4, 6, 8, 10μm respectively ( the maximum vector height of the parabola is defined as the maximum distance between all points on the parabola and the intersection point of the vertex normal line and the front surface of the mother lens ), and then the curvature radius of the two parabolas is calculated by combining the curvature radius of the front surface of the mother lens and the radial diameter of the microlens. The optical structure parameters of the saddle microlens are shown in Table 1. The position of each microlens can be calculated according to the optical structure parameters and the layout of the microstructure array, as well as the specific conditions that the vertex normal of the microlens points to the curvature center of the front surface of the mother lens. The microlens are added to the front surface of the mother lens in Zemax to complete the modeling of the lens.

 

Table 1. The maximum vector height is 2μm Optical structural parameters of saddle surface microlenses

info-953-187

 

3.4 Imaging simulation

The data of the myopic model eye is added to the Zemax sequence mode, and the non-sequence component is inserted in front of the model eye. The designed microstructure array lens is placed in the non-sequence component for optical simulation of the lens-eye system. The spot diagram of the human retina and its front and back 1000μm defocus range is shown in Figure.2. Since only all the light of the maximum out-of-axis field of view passes through the microlens in the three fields of view of the microlens array glasses, the data of the radius of the diffuse spot with the above five maximum vector heights in the field of view are extracted and summarized in Table 2. At the same time, the average MTF value of the microstructure lens and the mother lens retina under the maximum out-of-axis field of view is sorted out, as shown in Figure.3.

 

Table 2. Diffuse spot radius of saddle surface microstructure glasses under maximum off-axis field of view.

 

info-858-211

info-956-924

 

e. H=10μm

Figure 2. Off focus column diagram of the lens eye system corresponding to the microstructure of the saddle surface.

 

 

info-622-360

 

Figure 3. Mean MTF values in two directions.

 

4. DISCUSS

 

It can be seen from Figure.2 that the light through the microlens array forms a blurry dispersion spot in the acceptable imaging signal range of the human eye, and cannot converge in the defocus range of 1000μm before and after the retina, so that the light through the microstructure does not stimulate the human eye adjustment or adaptive function in the form of defocus signal, thereby reducing the contrast of retinal imaging. At the same time, it can also be observed through Figure 3 that the MTF curve of the maximum out-of-axis field of view decreases rapidly, which also verifies that the microlens array will reduce the contrast of retinal imaging, so that the eyeball will no longer grow in order to obtain the maximum contrast, and achieve the effect of inhibiting the growth of the eye axis. By analyzing Table 2, it can be seen that when the vertex vector height of the saddle microlens is constant and the maximum vector height gradually increases, the dispersion spot in the maximum off-axis field of view will increase, and the corresponding contrast will also decrease.

It can also be observed from Figure.3 that in the maximum off-axis field of view, when the spatial frequency is in the range of 0~43lp/mm, the maximum vector height of the saddle microlens gradually increases, the average MTF of the lens-eye system will gradually decrease, and the average MTF in this spatial frequency range is greater than or equal to 0.05, which is still in the area that the human eye can distinguish and detect[12].Therefore, the spatial frequency is 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 40, 43lp/mm in the spatial frequency range of 0~43lp/mm . The average MTF data with the maximum vector height of 2,4,6,8 and 10μm are listed in Table 3.

 

Table 3. Mean MTF data of saddle surface microlenses with different vector heights and frequencies.

 

info-717-518

 

 

To represent the impact of the maximum vector height variation of the microlens on retinal contrast, multiple nonlinear regression was performed on the data in Table 3 using SPSS software. In the spatial frequency range of 0~43lp/mm, the maximum vector height H and spatial frequency F of the saddle surface microlens are used as independent variables, and the average MTF value under each vector height value is used as the dependent variable to establish the equation. The results of multiple nonlinear regression analysis are shown in Table 4.

 

 

Table 4. Results of Multiple Nonlinear Regression Analysis.

 

info-770-233

 

Based on the data in Table 4, the empirical formula of the maximum vector height of the saddle microlens and the average MTF at the specified spatial frequency is established :

 

info-707-51

According to Table 4 and formula (1), it can be seen that the correlation coefficient of the fitting curve for the actual data is 0.939, and the value is greater than 0.9, which indicates that the fitting effect of the curve is better. At the same time, from the empirical formula (1), it can be seen that when a spatial frequency in the range of 0 ~ 43lp / mm is selected, the maximum vector height of the saddle surface microlens will affect the average MTF value at this spatial frequency. When the maximum vector height is larger, the average MTF value is smaller, that is, the retinal contrast is lower. It can be seen that under the maximum off-axis field of view in this frequency range, the maximum vector height has a nonlinear negative correlation with the average MTF value at a certain spatial frequency, that is, under the maximum off-axis field of view, the maximum vector height of the microlens has a nonlinear negative correlation with the retinal contrast. Among them, in the frequency range of 0~15lp/mm, MTF decreases faster, and at the same time, MTF decreases slowly. The quantitative relationship between the structural parameters of the saddle microlens and the average MTF value provides a basis for better design of glasses based on contrast reduction to improve the effect of myopia prevention and control, and may provide new functional myopia prevention and control products for optometrists.

 

In order to compare the imaging effects of saddle and spherical microstructure array lenses under relatively close light passing rate conditions, saddle microstructure array lenses with a vertex vector height of 0.9μm and a maximum vector height of 1μm and spherical microstructure array lenses with a vector height of 1μm are established by using the modeling method in this chapter. Under the maximum off-axis field of view and the specified spatial frequency ( 10lp / mm ), they are compared with the average MTF value of the mother mirror. The analysis results are shown in Table 5. It can be found that in the simulation of the two glasses, the light does not all reach the image plane, and the light loss of the spherical microstructure array glasses is greater ; secondly, compared with the mother lens, the average MTF of the two glasses is significantly reduced, and the average MTF of the saddle surface is lower than that of the spherical surface. This shows that in the case of relatively small light loss, the saddle surface is better than the spherical surface in reducing the contrast of the retina, which is more conducive to inhibiting the growth of the eye axis.

 

Table 5. MTF and light passing rate of lens-eye system.

 

info-824-128

 

5. CONCLUSION

Saddle-shaped microstructure array glasses based on contrast principle use microlens to scatter the incident light, thereby reducing the stimulation of the incident light to the periphery of the retina and greatly reducing the contrast of the retina. At the same time, by quantifying the relationship between the microstructure parameters of the saddle surface and the contrast signal, it is found that under the maximum off-axis field of view, when a certain frequency is selected in the spatial frequency range of 0~43lp/mm, the maximum vector height of the microlens and the MTF average value of the mirror-eye system show a nonlinear negative correlation relationship, that is, under this condition, the maximum vector height of the microlens and the imaging contrast of the retina show a nonlinear negative correlation relationship. This quantitative relationship provides a basis for the design of more accurate control of the contrast regulation of myopia prevention and control glasses, and it is possible to provide optometrists with new and better functional myopia prevention and control products. By comparing with the spherical microstructure under the condition of low light loss, it is found that the saddle surface microstructure is more significant in weakening the retinal contrast, which is more helpful to slow down the development of myopia.

 

REFERENCES

 

[1] World Visual Report. Geneva: World Health Organization. 2020, license agreement: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO. Proc. of SPIE Vol. 13254 132541P-6

[2] Holden BA, et al. Global prevalence of myopia and high myopia and temporal trends from 2000 through 2050[J]. Ophthalmology, 2016, 123(5):1036-1042.

[3] Morgan IG, Matsui KO, and Saw SM. Myopia[J]. Lancet, 2012, 379(9827): 1739-1748.

[4] Walline JJ, et al. Interventions to slow progression of myopia in children[J]. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2011(12): CD004916.

[5] Feng Jiaojiao, Song Jike, Bi Hongsheng. Research progress on retinal regulation mechanism of form deprivation myopia[J]. Recent Advance in Ophthalmology, 2023, 43 (09): 736-741.

[6] Brown DM, Mazade R, Clarkson-Townsend D, et al. Candidate pathways for retina to scleral signaling in refractive eye growth[J]. Exp Eye Res, 2022, 219: 109071.

[7] Logan NS, Radhakrishnan H, Cruickshank FE, et al. IMI accommodation and binocular vision in myopia development and progression[J]. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2021;62(5):4.

[8] Chakraborty R, Ostrin LA, Benavente-Perez A, et al. Optical mechanisms regulating emmetropisation and refractive err rrors:evidence from animal models[J]. Clin Exp Optom, 2020, 103(1): 55-67.

[9] Huang J, Hung L-F, Smith E L. Effects of foveal ablation on the pattern of peripheral refractive errors in normal and form-deprived infant rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta)[J]. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 2011, 52(9): 6428-6434.

[10] Neitz M, Wagner-Schuman M, Rowlan JS, et al. Insight from OPNiLW gene haplotypes into the cause and prevention of myopia[J]. Genes (Basel), 2022, 13(6): 942.

[11] Zeng Chunmei, Hou Jialing, Yu Haomo, et al. A microstructure eyeglass lens and its design method[P]. ZL202311219214.3.

[12] Zhang Yimo Applied Optics [M] Electronic Industry Press, 2015: 579-581.